Blue Anorak

Last modified on Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:14:18

Match report

York City 2-2 Southend United

From: Matthew WEIR
To: southend@isfa.com
Date: Sun, 19 Dec 1999 17:05:15 -0000

A bad result— a team like York should be easy pickings and we should have been good enough to grab all three points. York didn't really create all that much and Mel didn't make a decent save all game— his best work coming from some nifty footwork following some dodgy back-passes.

We were gifted a first when Tolly (well at least I thought it was Tolly and not Carruthers but I was at the far end) got between the defence and keeper who came out and was able to roll the ball back to Connelly who rolled it into an empty net, although I was convinced he was going to Gridelet it! We should have already made it 1-0 as, early on, Morley (I think) missed a sitter in oceans of space at the far post following a left-wing free-kick, somehow dragging it across the goal when he surely had to score.

John Main, who popped on the supporters' coach at the end, reckoned we should have been 3 up at half-time, but IMHO that would have flattered us as the only other decent chance we had was Connelly being denied by Mimms following a great move— Jonesy went on a run before playing a ball in which Tolly dummied and Flash running through from midfield took in his stride before shooting but Mimms denied us a great goal with a low save to his left. All in all it was a fairly pleasing first half and we were the better team, York creating virtually nothing, but I felt our football was too often leading nowhere and we lacked a cutting edge to get in behind the defence.

The second half, in contrast, was disappointing. We allowed York back into the game by playing too deep and I felt that the game was beginning to slip away from us as Little— surprise, surprise— failed to give us that extra impetus by introducing a fresh pair of legs. As I've seen us throw leads away so often before it wasn't a surprise when York firstly went ahead when their striker was given too much space to get a decent finish in from a left-wing cross and then they went ahead from a direct free-kick. We should have got at least two free-kicks down the other end of the field as Riverdance had his heels clipped a number of times but they broke away and one of their players went on a run past a couple of our players before Dangerous Dave Morley produced a desperate-looking, but IMHO fair tackle, which the ref penalised and Mel was caught out again.

In his defence I'd say the wall was just at fault as it was for some reason in the middle of the goal— I hope Mel was trying to get it in to a sensible position and that was why he was standing on a post— but, whatever the reason, Mel was well out of position and was easily beaten by the free-kick. This now appears to be one of many errors Mel has made this season, and he has definitely lost his outstanding form of last year (although a mere mortal could hardly play that well for too long) and his name can surely no longer be automatically the first down on the team-sheet.

We did at least grab an equaliser, Carruthers finishing emphatically (!) from half a yard after Tolson's header had been tipped onto the bar. I thought we should have had all three points, but at least I'll just about be able to show my face (and shirt) in York without too much humiliation.

Ratings

Mel C
5 - Didn't have to make a save all game and at fault for their second, but dealt well with back-passes
Booty
6 - At least he's playing more like he did when he first joined, but surely Cross is worth a place?
Jones
7 - Did a step-over, and defended OK.
Coleman
7 - Typical Coley performance, but I'd still prefer to see a fit Newman in his place, giving us some leadership on the pitch.
Morley
6 - Typical Morley, comfortable on the ball, but gave away the free-kick and missed a sitter. If he could cut these simple errors out we'd have a class act on our hands.
Beard
6 - Not sure whether he's playing worse than last year or just unable to shine in a better team.
Maher
7- For his standards a good show. The Maher of Barnet (Away), sensible distribution of the ball, spreading play well and even getting the odd challenge in, however still not the answer to our midfield crisis - we need a leg-breaker!
Connelly
6 - Took his tap-in well, but otherwise failed to impress, the 5-3-2 didn't help but a strange unwillingness to try and take on an inexperienced left-back.
Houghton
6 - Also failed to have a go and get in behind the defence. Another unfulfilled talent.
Carruthers
7- Full of running as ever, but not much of a threat, though he did score.
Tolson
6 - According to the Carling Opta stats in the programme the man most off-side in the division! Trebled his assists, and got in his first successful tackle this season. Had a few half chances and hit the bar, but he still too Boere for my liking.

Subs

Prudhoe, Campbell, Newman, Clarke, Cross
0 - no match winning contribution from any of them, when we crying out for a sub to change the game. I wonder why?
Tinkler
0 - Chickened out of playing against his former club apparently with flu— yeah I believe you.

Basically everyone was very, very average - worrying as the boys were supposed to be up for this one. I hope I don't ever see them play when they couldn't give a toss. Worryingly its now 5 defeats and no wins in 7. And our traditional post-Christmas slump still to come...

Come on you Blues!
Matthew Weir

The year's results


© Luke Bosman Monday, 23 April 2007 at 21:14:18

No part of this site may be reproduced without my prior permission.

Contributions and updates to the site are always welcome.