Match report
Southend United vs. Charlton Athletic
From: Peter Cowell
Date: Thu, 03 Aug 2000 05:31:12 -0700
Well done to the committee for organising such a successful
testimonial for Ronnie— from some of the mail I saw about only a few
hundred tickets sold in the days leading up to the match, I bet the
committes underwear was in a terrible state! But it all turned out
well in the end and I enjoyed it.
What I found particularly pleasing was the way the Addicks fans
joined in all the applause: for the Pulse Cheerleaders, Ronnie
himself and at the half time presentation. They were great, and for
such a good attitude I hope they go on to win the Premiership.
As for the game itself, like others I find it very difficult to
judge the results of such games. However, I do feel nevertheless
that any team wants to get some wins under their belts (no matter how
meaningless) to give a bit of confidence before the real games start.
You can't tell me that if a team has lost all the pre-season
friendlies, it has the same measure of confidence as a team that has
won all its games.
I didn't feel there was too much difference between the two teams.
Granted, Charlton were slicker and had more cutting attacks than the
Blues but they weren't 3 divisions better. To me, given not a
substantial difference, it is a question of whether Charlton are going
to struggle in the Premiership or whether Southend are going to do
well in Division 3. The answer is probably a bit of both.
Charlton will do well to stay up, and we will do well to reach the
play offs. We could do it but I think a lot depends on the start we
get: a good one and we would gain confidence and players would perform
to their best; a bad one and panic would set in.
As far as the players are concerned:
- Mel was shaky, erratic and lacks cofidence (as do the defence in
him).
- Searle I'm impressed with— I reckon he's a better player
than Nathan is.
- Roget and Morley were okay but I still worry about
Leo's temperament (viz. the throw-in incident) and I don't rate his
reading of the game nor his distribution. Morley looks cool and
classy but I'm always waiting for a mistake.
- I can't wait for Whelan to get out there but, if he can't play
for 20 mins in a friendly like this, how on earth will he be fit for
the Brighton game? I just hope.
- Booty also played pretty well and was always prepared to shoot.
- Tinkler was a revelation. Swept up well, distribution good and pushed
forward for attempts at goal.
- Lee and especially Forbes, when he came on, were impressive.
- Houghton just about OK.
So if everyone was at least adequate, why then were Tolson and
Carruthers starved of good balls? Tolson looked good with his
lay-offs and his thunderous shot on the turn. Carruthers was anonymous
(but what do you expect if he doesn't get the ball?)
Summary is that we could do reasonably well and do have the
players to get to the play-offs if we have some luck and a good start.
But we need more penetration and Whelan needs to be fit.
Peter C.
|